You can contest a will only if you have standing, and standing means you’d be financially affected by the outcome: you’re an heir who would inherit if the will were thrown out, or a beneficiary under an earlier will who was cut out of this one. Being a relative isn’t enough. Being disappointed isn’t enough. The law limits challenges to people with something at stake, and it limits the grounds too. Disliking the result is not a ground. Proving the will was signed by someone who lacked capacity, or was manipulated, or didn’t follow the signing formalities, is.
Who’s allowed to contest a will
“Interested persons” have standing. That covers heirs at law, meaning the people who would inherit under intestate succession if there were no will, and beneficiaries under any prior will who would receive more if the current one failed. A child left out of a will has standing because that child would inherit without it. A friend named in an earlier will and dropped from a later one has standing. A neighbor who thinks the will is unfair doesn’t. Creditors generally can’t contest a will, since they’re paid regardless of who inherits.
The grounds that actually work
Lack of testamentary capacity is the most common. The person signing must have understood what they owned, who their natural heirs were, and what the document did. Capacity is judged at the moment of signing, and a dementia diagnosis alone doesn’t prove it was absent. Undue influence is the second: someone in a position of trust pressured or manipulated the person into a will that benefits the influencer, overcoming their free will. Courts look for a confidential relationship, active involvement in preparing the will, and an unnatural result. Fraud, forgery, and improper execution round out the list. Improper execution means the will wasn’t signed and witnessed as state law requires, which is the most technical ground and sometimes the easiest.
The deadline to contest a will is short
Once a will is admitted to probate, the clock starts. Many states allow only a few months to file a contest, and some run the deadline from the date interested persons received notice. A few allow challenges before probate is opened. Missing the deadline ends the challenge regardless of merit. Anyone considering a contest should find the state’s deadline immediately, because it’s usually shorter than they expect.
No-contest clauses
Many wills include a clause stating that anyone who contests the will forfeits whatever it left them. These clauses are enforceable in most states, which makes contesting risky for a beneficiary who received something. Many states won’t enforce the clause if the contest was brought with probable cause, meaning a reasonable basis, even if it ultimately failed. A beneficiary who received nothing has nothing to forfeit, so the clause doesn’t deter them. The clause changes the calculation for people who got less than they expected but more than zero.
What a contest costs and how it ends
Will contests are litigation. They involve depositions, medical records, expert witnesses on capacity, and often a trial. Attorney’s fees are usually paid by the contestant, though a successful contest may allow fees from the estate. Most contests settle, because the estate’s assets are frozen while the dispute runs and everyone loses value to delay and fees. A successful contest doesn’t rewrite the will. It invalidates it, and the estate passes under the prior will or, if there isn’t one, under intestate succession.
The bottom line
Can you contest a will? Yes, if you have standing, a recognized ground, and you act within a deadline measured in months. The grounds are about the process of making the will, not the fairness of its terms. A no-contest clause raises the stakes for anyone who was left something. The people who win are usually the ones with medical records, witnesses, and a clear story about who was in the room when the will was drafted.
Frequently asked questions
Interested persons: heirs who would inherit under intestate succession if the will failed, and beneficiaries of a prior will who would receive more. Relatives with nothing at stake and creditors generally do not.
Lack of testamentary capacity, undue influence, fraud, forgery, and improper execution. Unfairness of the terms is not a ground.
Often only a few months after the will is admitted to probate, depending on the state. Missing the deadline ends the challenge regardless of merit.
A provision that a beneficiary who challenges the will forfeits their inheritance. Most states enforce it, though many make an exception for contests brought with probable cause.
Courts look for a confidential relationship, the influencer’s involvement in creating the will, isolation of the person signing, and a result that departs sharply from earlier plans.
No. Capacity is judged at the moment of signing, and someone with a diagnosis can still have a lucid interval when the will is signed.
Medical records near the signing date, the drafting attorney’s notes, witness accounts of who was present, earlier wills, and records of financial transfers before death.
The estate passes under the most recent valid earlier will, or under intestate succession if none exists. A contest does not let the court rewrite the terms.
Trusts can be challenged on similar grounds such as capacity and undue influence, though the procedure and deadlines differ from a will contest.
The person bringing it usually pays their own lawyer, and the estate pays to defend the will. Some states allow fees from the estate when a contest succeeds.
Keep reading: Elder financial exploitation in Arizona · Small estate affidavit in Arizona · Estate planning and probate guides
Ready to meet your legal match?
Right case, right lawyer, zero awkward first dates. Tell us what happened and we’ll introduce you to attorneys who actually fit.
Get MatchedThis article is general information about will contests and probate litigation and is not legal advice. Laws differ by state and change over time, and the facts of your situation matter. For guidance on your own circumstances, consult a licensed attorney in your state.