Attorney Advertising. This profile is independent editorial content produced by Awesome Attorneys and is not a paid placement. Nothing in this article constitutes legal advice or creates an attorney-client relationship. See our Methodology and Publisher Disclosure below.

Cagle Pugh: A Firm Built on Community Association Law That Grew Into General Business Litigation

Cagle Pugh’s practice started with a specific, unglamorous niche — representing homeowners’ and condo associations — and grew outward into general business and construction litigation from there. That origin still shows in the firm’s structure: it’s one of relatively few Austin litigation firms with a genuinely deep bench in community association law alongside its broader commercial litigation work, a combination that comes from serving that specific client base for years rather than treating it as an afterthought.

Origin and Background

Gregory Cagle, a founding partner, earned his J.D. from Baylor University School of Law in 1998 and has been selected to the Super Lawyers list every year from 2020 through 2026, with Super Lawyers specifically categorizing his practice as Real Estate, Business Litigation, and Construction Litigation. Partner Kathleen M. Kilanowski has also been selected to Super Lawyers, with a practice spanning Real Estate, Business Litigation, Creditor-Debtor Rights, Insurance Coverage, and Nonprofit Organizations — the nonprofit-law specialty reflecting the firm’s community-association client base, since homeowners’ associations are typically structured as Texas nonprofit corporations. Partner Paul Byron Starr, who joined more recently, graduated cum laude from Baylor University in 1995 and received his J.D. from Baylor Law in 1997; he holds Martindale-Hubbell’s AV Preeminent rating and has practiced civil and commercial litigation since 2001. In total, four Cagle Pugh attorneys have been selected to Super Lawyers or Rising Stars.

Practice Concentration

The firm’s practice spans business litigation and disputes, construction defect litigation, real estate litigation, community association law (representing homeowners’ and condo associations), insurance coverage and defense, creditor-debtor rights and commercial collections, and general counsel work for nonprofit organizations. It is headquartered in Austin with additional Texas offices in Dallas, Houston, and San Antonio. For firms with a narrower single-practice focus, see our Business & Corporate Litigation directory.

Notable Work / Track Record

Cagle Pugh’s public materials describe general practice areas rather than specific verdict or settlement figures, and Awesome Attorneys did not identify independently sourced case-outcome data for this firm during research; that gap is disclosed here rather than filled with substitute language. What is independently verifiable is scale and tenure: partners with a combined 55+ years of community law and business litigation experience, four attorneys carrying current Super Lawyers or Rising Stars selections, and a genuinely statewide Texas practice spanning four offices.

Client Voice

Cagle Pugh’s Martindale-Hubbell profile indicates the firm’s lawyers have chosen not to display peer reviews on that platform, and Awesome Attorneys did not locate a substantial independent public consumer review sample (Google, Avvo, Yelp) for the firm at the time of research. This is a smaller public review footprint than several other firms in this directory, and Awesome Attorneys is disclosing that directly rather than presenting an incomplete picture as comprehensive.

Beyond the Courtroom

The firm markets itself specifically as “built by native Texans to serve community associations and businesses,” with a stated presence spanning the state from El Paso to Houston and Lufkin to Corpus Christi — a genuinely broad geographic footprint for a mid-sized litigation firm, driven substantially by its community-association practice, since HOAs and condo associations exist in every Texas region regardless of major-metro proximity.

Recognition for This Austin Business Litigation Firm

Peer-reviewed and third-party credentials: four Cagle Pugh attorneys hold current Super Lawyers or Rising Stars selections, a peer-nominated and independently researched distinction; and partner Paul Byron Starr holds Martindale-Hubbell’s AV Preeminent rating, the service’s highest. Awesome Attorneys did not identify a Texas Board of Legal Specialization board certification for the firm’s named partners in the course of this research and is noting that absence directly rather than implying a certification that isn’t documented.

Texas Legal Backdrop

Community (homeowners’) associations in Texas are governed primarily by Texas Property Code Chapter 209 (the Texas Residential Property Owners Protection Act), which sets specific notice, hearing, and assessment-collection procedures an association must follow before it can foreclose a lien or suspend an owner’s privileges — procedural requirements that generate a substantial share of community-association litigation when an association gets them wrong. Construction defect claims involving residential property are separately governed by Chapter 27 of the Texas Property Code (the Residential Construction Liability Act), which requires a specific pre-suit notice and inspection process before a homeowner can file a lawsuit against a builder. None of this is legal advice; the specific procedural requirements for any community-association or construction-defect matter should be confirmed with a licensed Texas attorney based on the actual facts and governing documents involved.

Awesome Attorneys Assessment

Cagle Pugh’s clearest, most specific differentiator is depth in a genuinely underserved niche — community association law — combined with broader construction and business litigation capability and a statewide four-office Texas footprint, all backed by four Super Lawyers-recognized attorneys. The honest trade-off is twofold: Awesome Attorneys did not find TBLS board certification documented for the firm’s named partners, which several other firms in this directory’s Business Litigation category do hold, and the firm’s public consumer review footprint is thin, making independent client-experience verification harder than at firms with a larger review base. For a homeowners’ association, condo board, or business facing a construction defect or community-governance dispute — the firm’s specific area of depth — that combination of niche expertise and statewide reach is a strong fit. For a client specifically prioritizing TBLS board certification as a screening criterion, it’s worth asking the firm directly about individual attorneys’ certification status, since certification records can change and this profile reflects research at a point in time.

Methodology and Sourcing

This profile was researched from Cagle Pugh’s official website (caglepugh.com), Gregory Cagle’s and Kathleen Kilanowski’s Super Lawyers profiles, Paul Byron Starr’s LinkedIn and firm bio, the firm’s Martindale-Hubbell and BBB listings, and U.S. News’s law firm directory. Awesome Attorneys did not independently verify TBLS board certification status for the firm’s partners and discloses that as a research limitation rather than asserting a certification not documented in available sources.

Publisher Disclosure and Independence Notice

Awesome Attorneys is an independent legal directory and editorial publication. This profile was not paid for, commissioned, or reviewed by Cagle Pugh or its attorneys prior to publication. Awesome Attorneys may in the future offer sponsored placement products to attorneys and firms, including this one, but sponsorship has no bearing on the editorial content, inclusion, or findings of this profile.